best natural eyeliner

5 Best Natural Eyeliner in 2022 (Organic & Non-Toxic)

An eyeliner can effortlessly define your eyes and create a dramatic look. But the ones available in the market contain harmful ingredients like SLS and parabens and may damage your eyes.

Here, I have selected the 5 best natural eyeliner that is safe to use without causing any irritation to your eyes.

Best Natural Eyeliner for Sensitive Eyes in 2022

  #1. PuroBIO Organic Eye Pencil

PuroBIO Organic Eye Pencil

The eye and brow pencil from PuroBIO is a certified organic product and is never tested on animals. Though it is an eye pencil, it also functions as an eyeliner as it provides intense color when applied. 

Additionally, it has a brush attached to the pencil for eyebrow filling. This multipurpose pencil has the goodness of sesame oil, sweet almond extracts, vitamin E, and several plant extracts. 

The eye pencil is free from SLS, SLES, mineral oil, and other harmful toxins. The pencil is available in three different shades suitable for all.


  • Certified organic and cruelty-free product
  • Tested for Nickel content
  • Contains no SLS or SLES
  • Made of natural plant extracts and organic oils
  • Contains no mineral oil
  • Can be used as an eyeliner and eyebrow filler


  • Color is not too intense

#2. Physicians Formula Waterproof Eye Definer

Physicians Formula Waterproof Eye Definer

This water-resistant eyeliner is intensely pigmented and can be applied smoothly with a single stroke. Create a bold smudged look or a dramatic cat-eye look with the pencil liner, and sharpen it when required with the sharpener provided with this pencil. 

The pencil eyeliners from Physicians Formula are dermatologically approved, cruelty-free and hypoallergenic, and can be used for the ones who wear lenses. Wear this pencil eyeliner all day without experiencing any discomfort or irritation.


  • Water-proof eyeliner pencil
  • Dermatologist tested
  • Safe for those wearing contact lens
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
  • Comes with a sharpener


  • Smudging issues

Check out – Best remineralizing toothpaste

#3. Burt’s Bees Soft Black Nourishing Eyeliner

Burt's Bees Soft Black Nourishing Eyeliner

The eyeliner from Burt’s Bees is made of Cedarwood that has been organically sourced and is a  natural alternative for chemical-clad cosmetic products. The eyeliner has the goodness of jojoba oil, mango oil, and meadowfoam seeds that take care of your eyes.

The liner gives instant color to your eyes and the cosmetic can be applied to the lower and upper lashes effortlessly. It is free from phthalates, talc, parabens, silicones, SLS, or synthetic fragrances.

The product is not tested on animals and is ideal for daily use. It is available in four different shades, i.e., brown, black, blue, and green.


  • Completely natural products used
  • Has goodness of jojoba oil and mango oil
  • Parabens and Phthalates free
  • Fragrance-free eyeliner
  • Can be used for the sensitive eyes
  • Available in 4 different shades


  • The colors are not too intense

You may like to read – Best vegan lip balm

Best Organic Liquid Eyeliner

#4. Physicians Formula Organic Liquid Eyeliner

Physicians Formula Organic Liquid Eyeliner

This organically designed liquid eyeliner from Physicians Formula is densely pigmented to provide you with the deepest shade that does not wear off even after several hours. Smudge-free and flawless, this eyeliner is all you need to make your makeup complete.

A single stroke is all you need to define your eyes, and you are all set to look glamorous effortlessly. 

Made of organic products like Aloe Vera, Chamomile oil, jojoba oil, and cactus flower extracts, this is ideal for sensitive eyes. The applicator has a fine brush tip that creates stunning looks in seconds.


  • Smudge-fee
  • Infused with organic oils and plant extracts
  • Intense liquid liner
  • Easy to apply with a fine brush tip
  • Soothes and nourishes the eyes


  • Not water resistant

Also read – Best organic tinted moisturizers with spf

#5. Neutrogena Liquid Eyeliner

Neutrogena Liquid Eyeliner

The brand is known for its skin-friendly products, and this liquid, highly-pigmented eyeliner is designed to wear all day without melting or cracking. It is water-resistant and can provide clear lash strokes for a dramatic eye. 

Made of natural ingredients like coconut and honey, this eyeliner is smudge-free and dries quickly without messing up.

Draw the lines perfectly and confidently with the user-friendly applicator with a sharp tip that allows you to create your favorite winged stroke. The eyeliner is gentle on the eyes and has hypoallergenic properties.


  • Provides delined and solid black stroke
  • Comes with a sharp brush tip to provide clear lines
  • Hypoallergenic and does not cause any eye irritation
  • The user-friendly applicator makes application easier
  • Dries up quickly and do not flake or fade
  • Water-resistant eyeliner
  • Made of natural ingredients 


  • May cause eye irritation

Also read – Best organic lotion for dry skin


My personal favorite is Neutrogena Liquid Eyeliner that has the goodness of coconut and honey. Apart from being hypoallergenic, it is water-proof and smudge-free.

The second eye cosmetic that has secured a place in my bucket list is Physicians Formula Organic Liquid Eyeliner which is smudge-free and gives intense color in a single stroke.

If you are looking for an eye pencil, go for PuroBIO Organic Eye Pencil as it has the goodness of sesame oil and sweet almonds. You can also use it as an eyeliner and eyebrow filler (you get a brush for eyebrow filling).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *